Home · Retained search for startups
Retained executive search · startups · New York City

Retained executive search for New York's startups.

Retained CTO and VP Engineering search for VC-backed startups in New York, from the first technology leader to the one who scales the team. Exclusive, dedicated, and committed until it's filled.

100%
of retained searches filled — every one since 2015
96%
of 50+ placements since 2015 still in role at 12 months
30 days
typical time to a secured hire from engagement
12 months
replacement guarantee as standard, whatever the reason
Measured across 50+ retained searches Edison Hill has run since 2015.
Why retained, for a startup

The cost of getting it wrong isn't the fee. It's the year.

A technology leadership hire is not a vacancy to be closed. It is a decision about who sets the architecture, hires the team, and carries the roadmap in front of your board.

Retained means we work exclusively on your search, on a dedicated basis, and are committed to it until it's filled. Contingency recruiters are paid only if their candidate lands, so they're incentivised to send volume across many clients at once. Yours is one appointment, made correctly, once. That is a deliberate constraint on us as much as a commitment to you: it's why every retained search we have run since 2015 has been filled.

Start by getting the brief right, not by looking at resumes. The most common reason a CTO search fails is that the founders, the board and the investor each had a different job in mind. Technology leadership appointments should begin with the business challenge, not the job title.

First leader, or the one who scales it

Which technology leader does your startup need?

Groundwork: You're building the first thing that has to work.

At Groundwork, the job is still building — not managing a build. The right leader is closer to a technical co-founder than an executive hire.

What the right leader at this phase has usually done:

  • Has personally shipped a v1 product before, not just overseen one
  • Comfortable writing code weekly, not just reviewing architecture
  • Makes fast, reversible decisions rather than seeking process or consensus
  • Can wear product, infra, and hiring hats in the same week
  • Has an instinct for what to build now versus what to defer — resists over-engineering
  • If AI is core to the product: has actually shipped an AI feature end-to-end, not just experimented with one

Ascent: The team is growing faster than the systems holding it together.

Ascent is the inflection where founder-led engineering has to become a structured org — usually mid-Series A to Series B, team scaling past the point one person can hold in their head.

What the right leader at this phase has usually done:

  • Has scaled a team through roughly this same headcount range before — 10 to 40 engineers
  • Builds process without killing velocity — introduces just enough structure, not a full framework
  • Has hired and let go of engineering managers, and can tell you what they got wrong the first time
  • Treats technical debt as a business trade-off to be sequenced, not an emergency to eliminate
  • Has a point of view on when to introduce AI-assisted workflows team-wide, and what governance that needs

Not sure which phase you are in? Eight questions, instant result: the CTO Phase Assessment.

The roles

  • Chief Technology Officer: first-time appointments post-Series A, B and C, and successor appointments. Our CTO search
  • VP Engineering: scaling delivery under investor timelines
  • Director of Engineering and the leadership layer beneath the CTO
Before you start

Five questions to ask before hiring a CTO.

  1. What does success actually look like over the next 18–36 months? Not a list of responsibilities or technologies. Define the outcomes before defining the candidate.
  2. Are we looking for the right experience, or simply the right job title? Evidence of relevant achievement matters more than title alone.
  3. Have we designed the leadership structure around the business's actual needs? Where should accountability for AI, product, engineering, enterprise technology and governance sit?
  4. Do we understand what will motivate the person we appoint? Does the company's stage of development match the environment in which they've demonstrated their strongest performance?
  5. Have we explored the entire relevant talent market? Some of the strongest candidates may be happily employed, not visible on job boards and completely unaware of your business. A credible search should identify and assess those individuals too.

From Warren's October 2026 market update: AI is raising the bar for technology leadership.

How the search runs

Four steps, run the same way every time.

The consistency is what produces the number. Skip a step and the 96% is just a claim.

01

Behavioural job survey

We get every hiring stakeholder aligned on what “right” actually means — before a single candidate is approached.

02

Deep market mapping

The whole addressable market, mapped and screened — not a shortlist drawn from whoever happens to be looking.

03

Competency-based screening

Structured, video-based assessment against the agreed brief, so every candidate is measured the same way.

04

Onboarding & retention

The search doesn’t end at the offer. It ends when the hire is embedded — which is why they’re still there at 12 months.

The full method

Straight answers

Retained search for a startup, answered straight.

How do I find a CTO for my recently funded startup?

Start by getting the brief right, not by looking at resumes. The most common reason a CTO search fails is that the founders, the board and the investor each had a different job in mind. We run a behavioural job survey with every stakeholder first, map the full market against that agreed brief, and screen every candidate the same structured way. For a Series B CTO in New York, expect a secured hire around 30 days from engagement.

What is a retained search firm, and why not contingency?

Retained means we work exclusively on your search, on a dedicated basis, and are committed to it until it’s filled. Contingency recruiters are paid only if their candidate lands, so they’re incentivised to send volume quickly across many clients at once. For a pivotal leadership hire that incentive is pointed the wrong way. Every retained search we have run since 2015 has been filled.

Does a startup need a CTO or a VP Engineering first?

At Groundwork, the job is still building — not managing a build. The right leader is closer to a technical co-founder than an executive hire. Ascent is the inflection where founder-led engineering has to become a structured org — usually mid-Series A to Series B, team scaling past the point one person can hold in their head. Which phase you are in decides the brief, which is why we start there.

How long does a CTO search take?

Typically your new hire is secured within 30 days of engaging us. The variable is rarely the market — it’s how quickly the hiring group can agree what they’re actually looking for, which is why we front-load that work.

What happens if the hire doesn’t work out?

Every placement carries a 12-month replacement guarantee as standard — if they leave, for any reason, we run it again. In practice it’s rarely called on: 96% of the people we place are still in role 12 months later.

Hiring your startup's first technology leader, or the next one?

Fifteen confidential minutes on the role and the market. No pitch deck.